Skip to main content

Let Me Say What We're All Thinking

 

The three questions won't beat the behemoth algorithm. 


True, but that is not the point.

The three questions are not going to defeat big tech. The algorithm isn't sitting in a server farm somewhere, nervous about what I built. Meta has tens of thousands of engineers and decades of behavioral data and more money than most governments. A mom with three questions is not going to out-engineer that.


So why bother.


Because beating it was never the point.


The algorithm still runs whether you ask the questions or not. The feed is still engineered. The slot machine is still in your pocket. The platforms are not dismantled by awareness. They were not built to be.


What the three questions do is much smaller and much more honest than defeating anything.


They make you a less automatic target.


That's it. That's the whole claim.


A person who pauses and thinks about who made this, who benefits from my attention, what do they want me to feel, is harder to move than a person who doesn't. Not immune. Not victorious. Just less automatic. And less automatic, practiced over time, passed down to children before their habits are fully formed, compounds into something substantial. 



We have been here before.


Reading a nutrition label didn't defeat the food industry. McDonald's still exists. People still eat there. Nobody who read a label felt like they had beaten Coca-Cola.


What changed is that some people some of the time make a different choice than they would have made without the information. The pause now exists. The choice now exists. Before the label there was just the automatic reach and whatever happened next.


That's not nothing. That's actually most of what's possible against a system that size.



The honest version of what I'm offering is this.


You are not going to win. The feed is infrastructure now. It is woven into work and school and family life and you are not extracting yourself from it and neither are your kids.


But you can stop losing so automatically.


You can build the habit of asking before you act, thinking before you react. You can notice what the feed is doing to your attention and your mood and your sense of what matters. You can teach your kids to do the same before the patterns are so deep they feel like personality.


That is a different relationship to the feed than the one most people have. Not a perfect one. Not a finished one. A conscious one.



I am not selling you a victory.


I am selling you a pause.


In an environment engineered for speed and automaticity, a pause is the most subversive thing available to an ordinary person. Not a protest. Not a boycott or an app that blocks other apps.


Just a half second of friction between you and whatever the feed wants you to do next. A pause to establish your own intent vs what the feed wants you to feel. 


The algorithm was built to handle your resistance. 

It was not built for your conscious attention. The deliberate kind. The kind that looks at the thing directly and asks what it is and who it serves.


That is what the three questions are for.


Not victory. Just consciousness.


That turns out to be enough


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

They Built the Park Now They're Hiding in the Kitchen

  There is a scene in Jurassic Park that seems spot on for our situation, where the algorithm is concerned.  The chaos theorist, the one who was right from the beginning is played by Jeff Goldblum. He sits across from the park's creator and says "Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn't stop to think if they should." Hammond waves it off. He's proud. He built something extraordinary. The miracle is real. The problems are manageable. Then the raptors get out. Remind you of anything. I have been watching the AI companies with their press releases and TED talks. The carefully worded statements about safety and responsibility and the tremendous potential for human flourishing. The interviews where the founders look just slightly haunted by uncertainty. They look like they heard something moving around in the dark outside the building. The miracle is real. They built it. It works. And now they are in the kitchen, backs against th...
Post a Comment
Read more

This Is Intentional

  You may have noticed, this blog is plain. No images or dramatic design. No visual chosen to make you feel something before you've read a word. That's intentional. Everything here argues that the tools used to hold your attention online are engineered to activate your feelings before you form a thought. It would be strange to make that argument on a website doing the same thing. What you'll find here is words, questions, and the occasional uncomfortable fact. What you do with them is up to you. The store is on Gumroad rather than Amazon. Amazon is optimized. Every element of it is designed to keep you there, show you more, and convert your attention into a purchase. It is very good at this. Gumroad is not optimized. It has the slightly unfinished feel of the early internet, back when a website was just someone putting something they made in front of people who wanted it. No algorithm. No sponsored results. No system studying your behavior to figure out what to show you ne...
Post a Comment
Read more

We Figured Fast Food Out, We'll Figure This Out Too.,

  In 2004 Morgan Spurlock ate McDonald's three times a day for thirty days and filmed what happened to his body. Super Size Me was a sensation. Disturbing, funny, impossible to look away from. It won awards. It changed conversations. McDonald's quietly retired the Supersize option shortly after it came out. A year later a woman named Soso Whaley did the same experiment differently. She ate McDonald's every day for a month too. She counted calories, made reasonable choices, and lost weight doing it. You probably haven't heard of her. Her documentary didn't go anywhere. Not because she was wrong. She wasn't wrong. But because a person making informed choices and coming out fine is not a story. It doesn't have an arc. Nobody needs to be saved. The audience has nowhere to put their anxiety. We are wired for the dramatic version. The cautionary tale. The before and after. The thing that is killing us. Here is what actually happened with fast food over the next tw...
Post a Comment
Read more